Quick answer
Timing, phrasing and the one sentence structure that does not start a fight. What to say, and what to have ready before you say it.
If this is an emergency
Call 911 if someone is unresponsive, having a seizure, breathing slowly or irregularly, or confused with a high fever. For a mental health or suicidal crisis, call or text 988 to reach the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, available 24 hours a day. This website is not monitored in real time.
Before you say anything
- Know what you are asking for. "Get help" is not a request. "Come to an appointment with me on Thursday, I have already booked it" is.
- Have the options researched, because a window of willingness closes in hours and you do not want to spend it searching.
- Decide what you will do regardless of their answer, and be prepared to mean it.
- If opioids are involved, have naloxone in the house before the conversation rather than after.
Timing
- Not while they are intoxicated. Nothing said will be retained.
- Not in the middle of an argument.
- Not in front of an audience, which produces defence rather than thought.
- Ideally after a consequence they have noticed themselves, when the ground is already slightly open.
The sentence structure that works
Talk about yourself and about specifics. Avoid the words always, never, and you are.
- "I noticed [specific thing]. I felt [specific feeling]. I am worried."
- "What do you make of it yourself?"
- "What would need to be different for you to think about changing?"
- "I am not able to keep doing this" — a statement about you, which cannot be argued with.
Compare with "you always do this" and "you are destroying this family", which invite a fight and reliably get one.
Ask more than you tell
This is counterintuitive and it is the most important part. Pressing the case makes an ambivalent person argue the other side, and they persuade themselves in the process.
So ask genuine questions and be prepared to hear the answers. "What do you get out of it?" is a real question and produces far more than any amount of evidence. Our page on motivational interviewing explains why this works.
When they say the predictable things
- "I can stop whenever I want." — "Would you be willing to try, for a month? I would find that reassuring." Not a challenge. An invitation.
- "It's not that bad." — "Maybe not. I am still worried, and I would like you to talk to somebody so I can stop."
- "You drink too." — Do not defend. "Possibly. I want to talk about you because I am frightened."
- "Leave me alone." — "All right. I love you, and I am here when you want to talk." Then stop. Pressing past this loses the next conversation.
Expect it to take several attempts
The first conversation rarely produces agreement. What it does is establish that the subject can be raised without catastrophe, which makes the third one possible.
Judge it by whether they will still talk to you, not by whether they agreed.
What not to do
- Ultimatums you will not enforce.
- Shame, which increases concealment without reducing use.
- Surprise confrontational interventions, which have a weaker evidence base than the alternatives.
- Waiting for rock bottom, which is not a strategy and has no evidential basis.
If there is any risk of violence
Do not have this conversation alone or at home. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is 1-800-799-7233.
Frequently asked questions
When is the right time to bring it up?
Not while they are intoxicated, since nothing will be retained. Not mid-argument, and not in front of other people, which produces defence rather than thought. The best moment is usually shortly after a consequence they have noticed themselves — a missed event, a difficult morning, something that landed — when the ground is already slightly open. Privately, calmly, and when you have time rather than on the way out of the door.
What words should I actually use?
Talk about yourself and about specifics, and avoid always, never and you are. "I noticed this specific thing, I felt this specific way, and I am worried" works. "What do you make of it yourself?" works. "I am not able to keep doing this" is a statement about you and cannot be argued with. Compare those with "you always do this" or "you are destroying this family", which invite a fight and reliably get one.
What if they get angry or deny everything?
Expect it, and do not escalate. Denial and anger are the common first responses and pressing past them costs you the next conversation, which matters more than this one. "All right. I love you and I am here when you want to talk" is a complete and effective ending. Judge the conversation by whether they will still speak to you afterwards rather than by whether they agreed to anything.
Should I ask them to stop or to get help?
Ask for something specific and small enough to say yes to. "Get help" is not a request — "come to an appointment with me on Thursday, I have already booked it" is. Have the options researched beforehand, because a window of willingness closes within hours and spending it searching for a phone number is how it gets lost. A concrete next step with a date on it converts far more often than a general appeal.
Why should I ask questions instead of making the case?
Because pressing somebody who is ambivalent makes them argue the other side, and they convince themselves in the process — so the harder you argue for change, the more time they spend articulating why they should not. Genuine questions produce the opposite. "What do you get out of it?" is a real question and yields far more than evidence does. People are persuaded much more by what they say themselves than by what is said to them.
Does an intervention work?
The confrontational surprise model familiar from television has a weaker evidence base than the alternatives and risks damaging the relationship you will need afterwards. CRAFT — Community Reinforcement and Family Training — has engaged treatment-refusing relatives at markedly higher rates in trials, works through you rather than requiring them to attend anything, and does not involve ambushing anybody. If you are considering an intervention, look at that first.
How many times should I bring it up?
More than once, and not constantly. The first conversation rarely produces agreement; what it produces is the knowledge that the subject can be raised without catastrophe, which makes a later one possible. Repeated daily pressure has the opposite effect and hardens the position. Space them, keep each one short and specific, and treat the goal as keeping the door open rather than winning the argument on the day.
Sources
- National Institute on Drug Abuse. Principles of Drug Addiction Treatment: A Research-Based Guide. nida.nih.gov
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. samhsa.gov
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Overdose Prevention. cdc.gov
- MedlinePlus, U.S. National Library of Medicine. medlineplus.gov
- Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration. National Helpline, 1-800-662-HELP (4357). samhsa.gov
Talk it through with somebody who can answer for your situation.
Verify your insurance